Table 5. Confusion matrix for each talker group in the /a/ vowel context. The first number in each cell represents the percentage of trials for that target given that response. Cells with responses less than 5% were removed for clarity. The second number, in parentheses, is the mean goodness rating

Naïve Response Novice L2 Response
Target /ʨ/ /ʨʰ/ /ʨ*/ /sh/ /s*/ Target /ʨ/ /ʨʰ/ /ʨ*/ /sh/ /s*/
/ʨ/ 34.4 (2.82) 58.3 (2.46) 5.2 (1.20) /ʨ/ 36.5 (3.03) 39.6 (2.63) 9.4 (2.89) 14.6 (2.86)
/ʨʰ/ 25.0 (2.38) 72.9 (2.73) /ʨʰ/ 11.5 (2.82) 78.1 (2.87) 9.4 (3.00)
/ʨ*/ 13.5 (2.23) 86.5 (3.01) /ʨ*/ 7.3 (2.29) 5.2 (1.40) 83.3 (2.96)
/sh/ 18.8 (1.94) 34.4 (2.70) 16.7 (2.31) 30.2 (3.34) /sh/ 13.5 (2.46) 85.4 (3.12)
/s*/ 15.6 (2.27) 84.4 (3.30) /s*/ 20.8 (2.85) 75.0 (3.22)
Advanced L2 Response L1 Korean Response
Target /ʨ/ /ʨʰ/ /ʨ*/ /sh/ /s*/ Target /ʨ/ /ʨʰ/ /ʨ*/ /sh/ /s*/
/ʨ/ 57.3 (3.04) 35.4 (2.71) 6.3 (1.83) /ʨ/ 68.8 (3.17) 31.3 (2.97)
/ʨʰ/ 13.5 (2.85) 85.4 (3.07) /ʨʰ/ 9.4 (3.00) 90.6 (3.26)
/ʨ*/ 5.2 (2.20) 6.3 (2.50) 87.5 (3.20) /ʨ*/ 97.9 (3.35)
/sh/ 39.6 (3.37) 58.3 (2.98) /sh/ 94.8 (3.43)
/s*/ 25.0 (3.00) 75.0 (3.22) /s*/ 95.8 (3.51)
L2, second language; L1, native.