표 1. | Table 1. 국내 말소리장애 연구에 사용된 지표들 | Indicators that were used as variables by Korean research on children with speech sound disorder of unknown origin

Classification Number of publications Variable Reference
Speech sound Auditory-perceptual and segmental characteristics Production accuracy/percentage of errors 30 Percentage of consonants correct (PCC), the number of articulation errors, presence of consonant errors, correctness, proportion of articulatory errors 2, 6, 8, 10, 11, 12, 15, 16, 18, 19, 24, 25, 26, 27, 29, 30, 35, 37, 40, 41, 42, 44, 45, 48, 49, 51, 53, 57, 59, 62
Type of error 4 Type of error 27, 41, 56, 69
Error patterns 9 Phonological error patterns (phonological process) 14, 15, 26, 27, 35, 41, 48, 49, 53
Phonetic inventories 1 Phonetic inventories 62
Phonological features 2 Percentage of feature retention, distinctive feature retention 26, 51
Auditory-perceptual and suprasegmental characteristics Phonation 1 Voice onset time 52
Rate 2 Speech rate, articulatory rate 38, 42
Pause 1 Length and frequency of pause, inappropriate pause 38
Disfluency 2 Disfluency type, disfluency score, incidence ratio of disfluency, distribution of disfluencies at syntactic location 1, 59
Acoustic-phonetic features 6 Fundamental frequency (Fo), highest Fo (Fhi), lowest Fo (Flo), semitone frequency range (PFR), jitter, shimmer, noise-to-harmonics ratio (NHR), voice turbulence index (VTI), soft phonation index (SPI), variation of Fo (vFo), variation of amplitude (vAm), mean dB, dB range, pitch, loudness, voice quality, length of friction intervals, breathing intervals, central moment, skewness, kurtosis, a center of gravity, variance, F1, F2, vowel space area, slope and amount of change of formant (F1, F2) 3, 5, 22, 24, 46, 61
Other factors Whole-word measurements 2 Phonological mean length of utterance (PMLU), weighted phonological mean length of utterance (PMLU-W), proportion of whole-word proximity (PWP), proportion of whole-word correctness (PWC) 30, 50
Consistency/variation 6 Consistency, variation of articulation (articulatory variability), variation/inconsistency of articulatory error 7, 9, 10, 16, 29, 53
Intelligibility 4 Speech intelligibility 5, 11, 42, 44
Acceptability 1 Speech acceptability 11
Structure/function Oral motor structure and function 2 Facial symmetry (resting symmetry and symmetry of voluntary movement), external structure, nonverbal movement, diadochokinesis (DDK), alternative motion rate (AMR), sequential motion rate (SMR) 22, 24
Speech perception 2 Speech perception 6, 60
Language Vocabulary 9 Receptive vocabulary, expressive vocabulary 2, 6, 19, 25, 37, 39, 40, 53, 57
Reading 1 Reading skill (word recognition) 36
Writing 1 Writing fluency and content scoring 45
Comprehension 1 Story comprehension 63
Cognition Phonological process Phonological memory 14 Word repetition (accuracy, reaction time), sentence repetition accuracy, non-word repetition (accuracy, variation, reaction time, type of errors, percentage of error types), digit span forward/backward (recall, retrieval scores, sequencing scores), rapid automatized naming, forward/reverse pointing of word, priming task result (retrieval distractor, sequencing distractor) 7, 13, 17, 23, 25, 28, 31, 33, 39, 40, 43, 55, 56, 63
Phonological representation 3 Score and reaction time on the phonological representation judgment task, retrieval accuracy, score and reaction time on internal awareness of phonological representation task 2, 20, 33
Phonological awareness 9 Phonological awareness 4, 20, 21, 31, 36, 39, 45, 55, 57
Intelligence 1 Nonverbal intelligence 25
Memory 1 Visual sequential memory, spatial memory, word order memory 43
Learning ability 1 Accuracy and implicit learning ability on sequence learning task 21
Others Internal characteristics 2 Communication attitude, self-esteem, self-efficacy 18, 58
Sustained attention 1 Score and response time on visual and auditory sustained attention task 19
Foreign language vocabulary 1 English vocabulary knowledge, English vocabulary learning score 25
Risk factors 1 Language and gross motor development, gender and early development, otitis media with effusion, socioeconomic status, family history 54
1. Ahn et al. (2013); 2. Bae et al. (2016); 3. Cho et al. (2021); 4. Choi & Ha (2018); 5. Eom & Shin (2018); 6. Ha (2016); 7. Ha (2020a); 8. Ha (2020b); 9. Ha & Seo (2019); 10. Han & Ha (2017); 11. Han (2010); 12. Hong & Sim (2011); 13. Hwang & Ha (2019); 14. Hwang & Kim (2015); 15. Hwang & Lee (2011); 16. Jang & Ha (2021); 17. Jeon & Ha (2021); 18. Jo & Kim (2017); 19. Joo & Ha (2018); 20. Jung et al. (2015); 21. Jeong & Yim (2016); 22. Kim & Kim (2019); 23. Kim et al. (2015); 24. Kim (2019); 25. Kim & Ha (2019a); 26. Kim (2014); 27. Kim (2015); 28. Kim & Ha (2019b); 29. Kim & Ha (2021); 30. Kim & Ha (2018a); 31. Kim & Huh (2021); 32. Kim et al. (2020); 33. Kim & Ha (2014); 34. Kim & Ha (2018b); 35. Kim (2010); 36. Ko & Kim (2010); 37. Ko et al. (2017); 38. Lee & Kim (2017); 39. Lee et al. (2018); 40. Lee & Ha (2018); 41. Lee & Lee (2015); 42. Lee & Shin (2016); 43. Lee & Kim (2014); 44. Lee (2018); 45. Min et al. (2015); 46. Nam & Yi (2010); 47. Oh & Ha (2020); 48. Park et al. (2017); 49. Park & Kim (2015); 50. Park (2015); 51. Park & Shin (2016); 52. Park & Lee (2016); 53. Pi & Ha (2020); 54. Pi & Ha (2021); 55. Pi et al. (2020); 56. Ryu et al. (2019); 57. Seo et al. (2017); 58. Seo & Shin (2014); 59. Shin & Ha (2015); 60. Won & Ha (2015); 61. Yang et al. (2018); 62. Yi & Kim (2019); 63. Yun & Lee (2020).