표 3. | Table 3. 모음 연장 발성과 관련된 음향 변수의 기술 통계 I(공명, 섭동, 운율): 단계 농담(gradation)으로 표현된 녹색 변수는 주 효과(시간)와 관련이 있고 주황색은 그룹×시간 상호작용과 관련되어 있다(표4, 5에서도 동일) | Descriptive statistics of acoustic variables related to sustained vowel I (resonance, perturbation, prosody). While graded green cell has to do with main effect (time), orange one is related to the group×time interaction (same in Table 4 & 5)
var. | Time | Fatigue | Mean | SD | n | var. | Time | Fatigue | Mean | SD | n |
B1 | Before | NoYes | 328.5326.1 | 158.3201.5 | 25 | NHR (main) | Before | NoYes | 0.0720.048 | 0.1100.061 | 25 |
After | NoYes | 356.4358.2 | 172.7260.3 | 25 | After | NoYes | 0.0250.033 | 0.0160.025 | 25 |
B2 | Before | NoYes | 381.6333.8 | 254.5193.9 | 25 | jit_local | Before | NoYes | 0.6500.523 | 0.7020.499 | 25 |
After | NoYes | 370.2397.6 | 241.8376.9 | 25 | After | NoYes | 0.4140.497 | 0.1310.349 | 25 |
B3 | Before | NoYes | 604.8741.2 | 601.0524.6 | 25 | shim_ local | Before | NoYes | 7.1256.028 | 4.8993.194 | 25 |
After | NoYes | 640.4745.2 | 431.2700.3 | 25 | After | NoYes | 5.3016.497 | 2.7163.516 | 25 |
f1_dB | Before | NoYes | 67.9668.23 | 9.838.23 | 25 | f0 | Before | NoYes | 208.7208.5 | 17.7829.82 | 25 |
After | NoYes | 67.3568.75 | 7.128.46 | 25 | After | NoYes | 206.9203.9 | 21.1918.79 | 25 |
f2_dB | Before | NoYes | 62.3362.90 | 9.858.95 | 25 | Q-tone | Before | NoYes | 22.0421.80 | 2.944.88 | 25 |
After | NoYes | 61.8363.34 | 8.869.54 | 25 | After | NoYes | 21.6921.22 | 3.613.26 | 25 |
f3_dB (main) | Before | NoYes | 47.2846.28 | 10.459.15 | 25 | intensity | Before | NoYes | 62.3563.14 | 7.585.44 | 25 |
After | NoYes | 41.9944.51 | 11.6011.39 | 25 | After | NoYes | 61.8962.89 | 7.056.94 | 25 |
HNR | Before | NoYes | 16.1916.99 | 5.363.83 | 25 | sd_int | Before | NoYes | 0.9881.290 | 0.4691.057 | 25 |
After | NoYes | 17.8217.27 | 3.153.09 | 25 | After | NoYes | 0.9400.895 | 0.3020.338 | 25 |
B1, 1st formant’s bandwidth; B2, 2nd formant’s bandwidth; B3, 3rd formant’s bandwidth; f1_dB, 1st formant’s energy; f2_dB, 2nd formant’s energy; f3_dB, 3rd formant’s energy; HNR, harmonics to noise ratio; NHR, noise to harmonic ratio; jit_local, jitter local; shim_local, shimmer local; f0, fundamental frequency; Q-tone, quarter tone; sd_int, standard deviation of intensity.